yagistat.jpg (29205 bytes)DR. YAGI REMEMBERED!

yagiw.gif (1495 bytes)e would be remiss as an antenna magazine if we didn’t include reference to Dr. Hidetsugu Yagi (1886 ~ 1976) whose contributions have had an enormous effect on the lives of so many people around the globe for so many years. It’s almost impossible to crack open a radio or antenna-related journal and not see the word (name) "Yagi". Most folks, at least those not involved in radio, would be surprised to know that those funny-looking multi-element TV antennas sticking up above their roof lines were originated from a concept and invention of Dr. Yagi’s. Now that’s a lot of antennas without regard to the endless variations of amateur radio antennas in that same name. But, even some may be surprised to know that Dr. Yagi was focused on the dielectric technology more than 50 years ago! In this month’s issue of antenneX for August 1999, we have an interesting story for you as brought to us from personal experiences by Stanley Whiteman, W1MDZ.

But, before we get into the story of how Stan and Dr. Yagi got together, let’s remember a bit of Dr. Yagi’s own story. First, let’s back up a little and delve into a couple of prolific inventors, named Nikola Tesla and Professor Shunkichi Kimura who had early influence on Yagi and his works. By the way, one thing that simply amazed me in doing this piece, as famous as Dr. Yagi is and considering all of the achievements, it is very difficult to find research documents dedicated to him. Yes, there's plenty written about his inventions, but not the man. I only hope to do him justice here on these pages. If any of our readers, especially those from Japan. want to shed more light on this historical subject, please come forward. As will be noticed below, there seems to be a gap in some of the events leading up to the works of Yagi. Japan appears to have a whole different view of an accomplished inventor named Nikola Tesla. Anyone wishing to set the record straight, please just let me know. There is a handy Interactive NotePad at the end of this article for your immediate use. More recent documentation seems in order. Too many times, brilliant inventors have had reputations diminished, tarnished, overlooked or simply forgotten, all for the wrong reasons.

JAPAN and TESLA
Nikola Tesla, apparently a brilliant inventor at the turn of the past century, has a number of books written about him, but, is a controversial person to put it mildly, at least in Japan. Although Nikola Tesla had influence on Japan, he was not so famous though even among the scientific community there. Some historians recently researching Tesla concluded quite to the contrary though, and have compared him on an inventive scale equal to Edison and Marconi. However, still today, his fame is not fully recognized in the country of Japan as these same researchers have found. Those researchers argue it is simply not true there was no relationship between Tesla and Japan, even if his critics say so. Well, books notwithstanding, just who is this Tesla?

The development of Japanese power industry started with the foundation of Tokyo Electric Lamp Company in 1883. In the following several years, the same kind of companies were also founded in Kobe, Kyoto, Osaka and other Japanese centers. Early system of transmission and distribution of electric power in Japan, as in America, was in essence Edison's DC system. But, after that as the demands for electric power increased, the spread of using a high-tension alternator has begun. At the same time, Tokyo Electric Lamp Company bought the alternator made in Germany. Osaka Electric Lamp Company, in the western part of Japan bought an alternator made by General Electric Company. The alternator license General Electric Company bought from the Westinghouse Company was the one which Tesla had sold to the Westinghouse Company, thus, this important invention originated with Tesla and led later to significant contributions in the field of Japanese communications technology.

One of our readers, Karl, DJ5IL, reports this additional background on Tesla: "He was born on July 10, 1856 in Smiljan, a small village in Croatia. He studied in Graz (Austria) and Prag (Czech Republik) and later went to America. On June 6, 1884 he arrived in New York with only a few cents in his pocket. In March 1885, the Tesla Electric Light and Manufacturing Company was founded. Tesla was a real genious and made many inventions. On February 8, 1943, he died in his Room in the Hotel "New Yorker", where he lived for his last 10 years."

Before the War between Japan and Russia, considering the pending need of military ships for wireless communications, the Japanese Navy had set up the Wireless Researching Committee in 1900. Soon after that, in 1902, Professor Shunkichi Kimura from the Japanese Naval College went to Europe and America together with a naval officer to investigate the wireless technology. Professor Kimura, who had already had some experiences from America, read Tesla's book about HF alternating current. He then asked Tesla to explain more about the wireless concept and visited Tesla's laboratory in Manhattan, USA. Tesla was 45 then and he had already started building The World Broadcasting Tower at Wardenclyffe in Long Island, USA and made the first step of realizing the dreamed-about "World System".

As reported, Tesla performed a fascinating demonstration of a giant Tesla coil for Kimura. Comparing to power transmission without wire, purportedly Tesla said that the wireless telegraphy was not at all such a great invention and rather put down the potential. Kimura wrote an essay about that event which stated: "After my visiting Tesla's laboratory and seeing the demonstration of his giant coil, it could be described as a giant snake winding all around. That experience of demonstration made me understand the efficiency of the electrical resonance at once. Sneering at the wireless communication as a great invention, Tesla said that he realized the meaning of the wireless transmission of power and wireless electrical lighting. Maybe that would be realized sometimes in the future, but for the present moment it is not useful for our research". It has been observed that Tesla's low opinion about the importance of the wireless telegraphy had something to do with personal envy of Marconi's recognition for the wireless over Tesla’s early achievements in this field.

However that may be, through this research, Kimura was convinced that their (Japan’s) technical attainment of wireless telegraphy was by no means inferior to that of the West. So, after returning to Japan, he tried to develop a unique Japanese system of his own. The result of this effort was to equip the patrol ship "Mikasa" with a wireless machine before the battle at the Japan Sea where "Mikasa" used it for transmitting information about the Russian Battle Fleet.

Now, enter Dr. Yagi. Kimura's successor in relationship with Tesla was a Japanese scientist Hidetsugu Yagi. He was a famous inventor of the television antenna who respected Tesla's work and it was Yagi who presented a paper on Tesla's power transmission without wire at an International scientific society in Japan. He was also known as a pioneer in the field of radio control in Japan, and respected Tesla's efforts also in that regard. So, now what about a "Yagi" antenna?

In his laboratories, beginning in 1924, Professor Yagi and his assistant, Shintaro Uda, designed and constructed a sensitive and highly-directional antenna using closely-coupled parasitic elements. The antenna, which is effective in the higher-frequency ranges, has been important for radar, television, and amateur radio The familiar Yagi TV antenna is a Yagi-Uda array, named after these two Japanese electrical engineers: Hidetsugu Yagi, who invented it in 1928, and Shintaro Uda, who perfected it for television reception in 1954.

Michael Brady of Oslo* goes on to say that "In this sense, array means having many elements, which is exactly what this type of aerial has. The metal grid at one end is a reflector. It focuses intercepted television signals on to the actual aerial in front of it, which is called the driven element, and this part of the array is connected by a cable to your TV. The principle is much the same as that of a silvered reflector at the back of a car headlight, which focuses the light emitted by an electrical lamp in front of it into a beam to light the road ahead.

In front of the driven element, away from the reflector, are several director elements, which are the spines. They sharpen the focus of the aerial in one direction, much as the lens of the car headlight directs the light from its reflector into a particular pattern. For the TV aerial, this pattern resembles a cone, which should be pointed directly at the local TV transmitter to receive signals from it. The rod along the axis of the aerial supports the elements mounted transversely on it and keeps them in their correct places, much as the frame around the car headlight holds the reflector and lens together.

The reason why the Yagi-Uda array has proved so successful as a VHF and UHF television receiving aerial is that, for such a small size, its performance is excellent. A similar performance from a parabolic aerial, of the type used to receive satellite television signals, would require a dish many times larger."

Then, Peter Buck of the Physics Department, Exeter College states*: "The surprising thing about the Yagi-Uda array television aerial is that most of it is not connected to the television at all. The only part that is linked to the receiver, via the coaxial cable, is the single pair of spines which comprise the dipole and lie immediately in front of the small metal grid or reflector.

The length of the dipole itself needs to be about half a wavelength in order to receive the television signal, but on its own it would be too weak in most areas. The reflector is a quarter of a wavelength behind the dipole, and adds significantly to the gain--or strength--of the aerial. All the other spines, known as directors, are in front of the dipole and they, too, are a quarter of a wavelength apart and half a wavelength long. Their job is to increase the gain of the aerial--so the weaker the signal, the more are needed.

There is a price to pay for this increased gain, and that is the directional properties of the aerial. A short aerial with few directors in an area close to a transmitter needs little care in aligning it, but a large aerial that is carrying the many directors necessary in areas with a weak signal, needs to be aimed very carefully at the local transmitter.

Terrestrial television transmission is ultra high frequency (UHF), which has a short wavelength, so the half-wave dipoles are short. FM radio is very high frequency (VHF) which has a longer wavelength, so the half-wave dipole needs to be longer. So, even though some FM radio aerials are similar in design, they need to be much larger.

Some television aerials have their spines, known as elements, in a horizontal plane--this means that the local transmitter is using horizontal polarization, while a vertically aligned aerial means that the transmitter is using a vertically polarized signal.

This arrangement helps TV watchers to avoid interference between transmitters which are located close together. FM radio transmission uses mixed polarization (horizontal and vertical) because many of the listeners are mobile, using portable radios or radios in cars, and are unable to maintain regular alignment of the aerial."

Alright, this may be "old stuff" to many, but I imagine just as many, especially the "new guys" only thought of the "Yagi" as just a word or name of an antenna and never considered its origins. From that standpoint "Dr. Yagi Remembered!"

BACK TO STAN’S STORY
Stan, who had spent some 10 years working in the CIA laboratories prior to the end of W.W.II, got involved in dielectrics. He was interested in building a compact antenna for Ham use and believed that such might be achieved through the powers of the dielectric. While working for Northwest Airlines and stationed in Japan, Stan decided to try and look up Dr. Yagi. With great determination, Stan located and went to Dr. Yagi’s home. Needless to say, this being right on the heals of the end of W.W.II, Stan was met at the front door by an apprehensive Mrs. Yagi. But Stan was able to convince her he was simply on a friendly visit, not any official Government purpose, and wanted very much to discuss a few innocent subjects with her distinguished and famous husband, Yagi San.

Stan became friends with Dr. Yagi and they talked at length about various technical subjects, finally leading into Stan’s current dielectric antenna concept. Was, Stan ever surprised to then learn that Dr. Yagi had been working on his own ideas and projects involving the application of dielectrics to antennas TWO YEARS EARLIER! However, Dr. Yagi’s work was concentrated for its use as a wartime radar antenna which could be mounted on a periscope to be raised and lowered. It would also have to be impervious to the elements of the salt water and great depths traveled by the submarines. (Courtesy of New Scientist, IPC Magazines Limited 1997*)

NOW HEAR THIS!
In this month’s issue, we are pleased to present this story of Stan and Dr. Yagi, our first full article in streaming audio! Hear this interesting story as told by Stan, W1MDZ in his own words by recording from his home in Danforth, Maine. I hope most of our readers now have sound cards and speakers attached to their computers as we would like to present more "live" articles in this manner, even video at some point. If you have audio and have the Windows 98 version of RealPlayer installed, you will still need to upgrade to RealPlayer G2. It’s free software for download and can be found at http://www.realplayer.com. Or, go here directly to the download page: http://www.real.com/products/player/downloadrealplayer.html?wp=dl0699&src=hp_butn,990706home_1&lang=en

They have a RealPlayer G2 Plus version too but it’s not free. Just follow the "Free Download" links. Those familiar with streaming audio know it is a web technology that allows you to listen to the file while its being downloaded, rather than a wave sound file that has to be downloaded entirely before playing. Plus, the RealPlayer sound file is only about 10% the size of a wave file. Even so, an entire article recording such as this one is about 3MB! BUT, it would be about 30MB in wave form making it unsuitable from practical use on the web.

If you want a quick test to see if your audio device is ready, try my streaming audio announcement and introduction of this article which has a link on the front cover, top right hand location. OR, just click right here"

CLICK TO LISTEN (or Test)


Plus, you can record to keep the article as the audio plays!
Just launch your sound recorder & be sure to have correct input/output selected,
OR, record to your tape recorder using the "line out" jack on the sound card.


But, for those of you who are "audio challenged" we haven’t forgotten you either. For you, we have a text version along with the diagrams of Dr. Yagi’s and Stan’s antenna concepts. However, I urge you to consider upgrading your computer so you won’t miss out on this exciting new feature we offer of a "talking magazine!" For about $50-$60 US$, you can add a sound card and speakers. The prices have really dropped on many such devices—so you can’t afford not to join in the fun! We hope to bring many more articles to life in the very words of its author. What a great innovation for posterity! Wouldn’t it be a thrill to hear the words in the actual voice of Marconi?

WHAT'S THE ISSUE?
Well. I’ve gone on too long again and I’d better get to the introduction of this month’s issue. Not only is our veteran writing team with us with their usual fine contributions, but some new blood as well. I think you are going to like this issue a lot!

THE AUGUST 1999 ISSUE NO. 28 CONTENTS:
OUR MONTHLY COLUMNS (plus this one by yours truly):
From the Shack A Guest Editorial by Richard Morrow, K5CNF
Our own Editor is back this month with an editorial that discusses his great satisfaction about the performance of his "no-holes roof-mounted" antenna farm and its ability to survive a recent violent storm with winds in excess of 100 MPH (160 Km). About a year ago, Richard wrote an article in the Ham WorkShop about this installation and his theory about its durability. Plus, it solved the problem of how to avoid the drilling holes in the roof at his home. That was a very popular article as apparently many others  live in stormy areas and are subject to losing antennas. The problem of holes in the roof has been a deterrent to this handy type of installation. Well, now as an update, Richard the results are in after that stormy test and Richard is most pleased as you will see.

Antenna Modeling by L. B. Cebik, W4RNL
Not only do we continue our tribute to Dr. Yagi, but L.B. continues his modeling column on the subject of Yagi antennas in this month's column entitled Why Tri-Banders Are Hard to Model. As L.B. states: "One of the most popular amateur radio antennas is the tri-band Yagi. It also happens to be one of the hardest antennas to model adequately, whether one is using NEC or MININEC. As a result, there are few, if any, reliable models available to the amateur modeler. The models that do exist tend to be done in one of the implementations of MININEC, unless they use a log-cell driver system. However, most of these models are proprietary. Moreover, many of them are used to guide final antenna design, but they do not represent exact models of the final design.

It may be useful to understand some of the limitations of trying to model tri-band Yagis. The account--which is very general and not tied to the specific circumstances surrounding any particular commercial antenna--may give some insight into why tri-bander models are hard to come by. In addition, it may give the owner of one of these antennas some cautionary notes lest he or she give undue trust to a hasty home-generated model of the station beam. Modeling tri-band Yagis requires the greatest of care."

Ham WorkShop by August Hoecker, W8MIA
August Hoecker has another one of his Useful Accessories articles in his column this month called THE RF NOISE GENERATOR With A COMPANION NOISE DETECTOR. Those of you who are not familiar with the use of an RF Noise Generator may be saying "RF Noise!" I have enough noise now, I do not want to generate any more noise, Do I? W8MIA's answer to this common reaction is yes! You just might gain a good deal of receiver performance through the use of this very simple to build and easy to use piece of RF Test Equipment along with its companion, the noise detector. Read August's column this month and find out how!

AUGUST 1999 FEATURE ARTICLES IN THE LIBRARY:

Dr. Yagi & W1MDZ Dielectric Antenna Experiments
An Article in Streaming Audio and Written Text Plus Diagrams!
By Stan Whiteman, W1MDZ and Richard Morrow, K5CNF

Welcome folks to our first full size article in streaming audio. It is hoped most of our readers have audio devices installed in their computers and thus able to fully enjoy this article "brought to life" by the actual voices of the authors, W1MDZ & K5CNF. When we received a taped recording from Stan Whiteman, W1MDZ, about his experiences with a dielectric antenna on two meters, it caught our attention. We found it most interesting to learn Stan had built a directional VHF aircraft antenna right after the war. Also, while stationed in Japan, he had met and talked with Dr. Hidetsugu Yagi at the home of this famous Japanese Electrical Engineer and Physicist. Much to Stan's surprise, he learned Dr. Yagi had worked on the dielectric technology two years earlier, except that his project applied to a use for radar on submarines during W.W.II. Dr. Yagi explained they needed a radar antenna that could be raised and lowered with the periscope and be impervious to salt water so as not to de-tune. They discussed and compared notes about the dielectric antenna Dr. Yagi had designed and the one Stan had constructed. I might add that Stan had previously spent some 10 years working in the laboratory of the USA CIA on various projects. We think you will really enjoy this article "brought to life" by the voices of the authors. BUT, for those of you without audio, there is also a text version. Plus, diagrams of Dr. Yagi's and Stan's antenna designs are also in the Library with the article. Don't dare miss this one!

High-Gain, Wide-Band Yagis for 10, 6, and 2 Meters
by L. B. Cebik, W4RNL

There is a very interesting 20-meter Yagi design called the Optimized Wideband Antenna, or OWA. Although only one of several designs within this genre, developed by Nathan Miller, NW3Z and Jim Breakall, WA3FET, using an optimizer program no longer available, the 20-meter version is one of the most adaptable. It employs 6-elements in the space that many other designs use 5. Our tribute to Dr. Yagi continues and it seems the possible variations of his antenna concepts endless as described in this article by the popular author, L.B. Cebik.

LOOPS of Olden Days - Part 4
by Harold Allen, W4MMC

As sated before, Harold has been experimenting with Loops since the 1940s and considered an expert. The is the fourth in a series of four articles about "LOOPS of Olden Days". Like the preceding articles this one will place special emphasis on explaining many of the efficiency factors and considerations involved in the development and testing of several configurations of small compact transmitting loop antenna systems. Since this is the last article of a series of four articles about "LOOPS of Olden Days", if you have not read the preceding three articles in this series we suggest you read them as well to follow the complete concept. They are reserved for your reading pleasure and background information in antenneX’s "Archives III Reading Room". This is an excellent and well-detailed article by Harold as usual. If you want to understand about Loops, don't miss these articles!

ANTENNA TUNERS, Setting the Record Straight
By: Mel Murphy, W6VEJ

Another writer has joined us this month on a refreshing subject about what antenna tuners really do for you. Mel Murphy, W6VEJ says: "I am quite sure that few if any, in the amateur radio community, will argue with the premises that the antenna is one of the most important components of their station. In fact I will be so bold as to say the most important component. We all know that the best rig money can buy will NOT give a good account of itself if it is coupled to a poor antenna. We also know that a rig that is many years old, but in good repair, WILL give a good account of itself if it is properly coupled to a good antenna." Properly coupled to the antenna? Ah, there lies the meat of this article! Mel examines that concise statement and defines what it really means. If you have wondered about the role the tuner really plays in your ANTENNA SYSTEM, you should read this one!

My Goofy Loop
by
Paul Beringer, W7EAI

This is Paul's first article for us and he wanted to tell you about an antenna he has been using for over a year. The impetus for this antenna was spawned by a design for an apartment loop antenna Paul ran across. After reading books about the theory of Loops, Paul's final design came about mainly after several trial and error attempts and simple "seat of the pants" instinct. Although it does not conform to any other antenna designs he found, Paul says it has performed amazingly well for its size and had several compliments about its unique shape and method of feeding. Paul also admits, "I have a very limited knowledge of antenna theory and my eyes glaze over every time I begin reading about the esoteric properties of shape, wire size, impedance and the like. This "goofy loop", as I like to call it, works and works well." Those of you, especially like Paul, who prefer the "meat and potatoes" approach rather than deal with equations and theory, you will enjoy this article!

Håkan's CFA Project Tour ~ "My view of the CFA"
By Håkan Widenstedt

Hakan is an engineer working with short-wave broadcasting for Radio Sweden at a place called Hoerby in the south of Sweden. As described by Hakan, "with great interest for years, I have followed this fascinating and mysterious story about the CFA. When I saw the articles in antenneX I finally decided, rather than simulate, to practically learn more about it by building one. To understand how the CFA is working, I think it's a good approach to study how the fields are created around conventional antennas compared to the CFA. It's a most interesting story! I never gave this a thought before I started to study and learn about the CFA over a period of several years." This is a good article about the problem areas (usually the tuning) that usually cause most 'would-be' CFAers the most difficulty in getting one of these devices to work properly. What's really different about this article? Well, Hakan, has devised an interesting method for monitoring the fields during this difficult and very sensitive tuning effort. This is the very problem most have been wrestling with! Finding the proper spot of optimization. The article includes 10 pictures showing Hakan's various stages of his present CFA project, plus diagrams, including the one that describes the "probes" for monitoring the fields during tuning. Readers, it looks like the CFA is here to stay because it really does work! We know of similar projects going on in at least 9 countries! If you need a compact antenna that can be stuck in a closet or attic, and perform your needs, look no further!
 

Well, there you have it, folks—thanks for listening and remember, the reading lamp is always on for you in the reading rooms. If I can be of further help, I'm just a Stone's Throw! away. jack@antennex.com


Print/Save Article

Back to Contents


Send mail to webmaster@antennex.com with questions or comments.
Copyright © 1988-1999 All rights reserved worldwide - antenneX©
Last modified: March 24, 2005